diff --git a/app/Views/certificate_installation_index.php b/app/Views/certificate_installation_index.php
index 87da263..e0c8355 100644
--- a/app/Views/certificate_installation_index.php
+++ b/app/Views/certificate_installation_index.php
@@ -48,8 +48,8 @@
                             <table id="certificatesTable" class="table table-striped table-hover border" style="width: 100%;">
                                 <thead class="table-primary">
                                 <tr>
-                                    <th style="width: 32%">Certificate</th>
-                                    <th style="width: 38%">Act Report</th>
+                                    <th style="width: 35%">Certificate</th>
+                                    <th style="width: 35%">Act Report</th>
                                     <th style="width: 10%">Issue Date</th>
                                     <th style="width: 8%">Validation</th>
                                     <th class="text-center" style="width: 12%">Action</th>
@@ -188,8 +188,13 @@ $(function () {
                             let fullname = cert.fullname;
                             let activity_subject = cert.activity_subject;
 
+                            let user_check    = cert.user_validation_at ? 'checked' : '';
+                            let spv_check     = cert.spv_validation_at ? 'checked' : '';
+                            let manager_check = cert.manager_validation_at ? 'checked' : '';
+
                             let issuedate = '-';
                             let validationBadge = '';
+                            let statusBadge = '';
 
                             if (issuedateRaw && issuedateRaw !== '0000-00-00') {
                                 let date = new Date(issuedateRaw);
@@ -200,13 +205,44 @@ $(function () {
                             }
 
                             if (status == 'unvalidated') {
-                                validationBadge = '<div class=""><span class="badge bg-warning text-dark">unvalidated</span></div>';
+                                // validationBadge = "<div class=''><span class='badge bg-warning text-dark'>unvalidated</span><br></div>";
+                                validationBadge = '<div class="">' +
+                                                    '<span class="badge bg-warning text-dark mb-1 p-1 px-2">unvalidated</span><br>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check text-sm">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + user_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">TSO</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + spv_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">SPV</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + manager_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">Manager</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                '</div>';
+                                statusBadge = '<span class="text-danger">❋</span>';
                             } else {
-                                validationBadge = '<div class=""><span class="badge bg-success">validated</span></div>';
+                                // validationBadge = '<div class=""><span class="badge bg-success">validated</span></div>';
+                                validationBadge = '<div class="">' +
+                                                    '<span class="badge bg-success mb-1 p-1 px-2">validated</span><br>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + user_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">TSO</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + spv_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">SPV</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + manager_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">Manager</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                '</div>';
                             }
 
                             return [
-                                `<strong>${certname}</strong><br><small class="text-muted">Cert# : ${certnumber}</small>`,
+                                `<strong>${statusBadge} ${certname}</strong><br><small class="text-muted">Cert# : ${certnumber}</small>`,
                                 `<a href="javascript:void(0)" class="activity-report-link text-decoration-none" data-certid="${certid}" data-actid="${actid}" style="color:#d43215b0;">#${actid} - ${activity_subject} &nbsp;<i class="fa-solid fa-up-right-from-square"></i></strong><br><small class="text-muted">Owner : ${fullname}</small></a>`,
                                 issuedate,
                                 validationBadge,
diff --git a/app/Views/certificate_maintenance_index.php b/app/Views/certificate_maintenance_index.php
index facb6b4..871b8d9 100644
--- a/app/Views/certificate_maintenance_index.php
+++ b/app/Views/certificate_maintenance_index.php
@@ -216,10 +216,15 @@ $(function () {
                             let fullname = cert.fullname;
                             let activity_subject = cert.activity_subject;
 
+                            let user_check    = cert.user_validation_at ? 'checked' : '';
+                            let spv_check     = cert.spv_validation_at ? 'checked' : '';
+                            let manager_check = cert.manager_validation_at ? 'checked' : '';
+
                             let issuedate = '-';
                             let expirydate = '-';
                             // let statusBadge = '<span class="badge bg-warning text-dark">need validation</span>';
                             let validationBadge = '';
+                            let statusDot = '';
 
                             if (issuedateRaw && issuedateRaw !== '0000-00-00') {
                                 let date = new Date(issuedateRaw);
@@ -250,15 +255,45 @@ $(function () {
                             }
 
                             if (status == 'unvalidated') {
-                            
-                                validationBadge = '<div class=""><span class="badge bg-warning text-dark">unvalidated</span></div>';
+                                // validationBadge = "<div class=''><span class='badge bg-warning text-dark'>unvalidated</span><br></div>";
+                                validationBadge = '<div class="">' +
+                                                    '<span class="badge bg-warning text-dark mb-1 p-1 px-2">unvalidated</span><br>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check text-sm">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + user_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">TSO</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + spv_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">SPV</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + manager_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">Manager</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                '</div>';
+                                statusDot = '<span class="text-danger">❋</span>';
                             } else {
-                                validationBadge = '<div class=""><span class="badge bg-success">validated</span></div>';
+                                // validationBadge = '<div class=""><span class="badge bg-success">validated</span></div>';
+                                validationBadge = '<div class="">' +
+                                                    '<span class="badge bg-success mb-1 p-1 px-2">validated</span><br>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + user_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">TSO</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + spv_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">SPV</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + manager_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">Manager</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                '</div>';
                             }
 
                             return [
                                 // index + 1,
-                                `<strong>${certname}</strong><br><small class="text-muted">Cert# : ${certnumber}</small>`,
+                                `<strong>${statusDot} ${certname}</strong><br><small class="text-muted">Cert# : ${certnumber}</small>`,
                                 `<a href="javascript:void(0)" class="activity-report-link text-decoration-none" data-certid="${certid}" data-actid="${actid}" style="color:#d43215b0;">#${actid} - ${activity_subject} &nbsp;<i class="fa-solid fa-up-right-from-square"></i></strong><br><small class="text-muted">Owner : ${fullname}</small></a>`,
                                 issuedate,
                                 expirydate,
diff --git a/app/Views/certificate_training_index.php b/app/Views/certificate_training_index.php
index 0c1edc1..b444a1f 100644
--- a/app/Views/certificate_training_index.php
+++ b/app/Views/certificate_training_index.php
@@ -192,8 +192,13 @@ $(function () {
                             let fullname = cert.fullname;
                             let activity_subject = cert.activity_subject;
 
+                            let user_check    = cert.user_validation_at ? 'checked' : '';
+                            let spv_check     = cert.spv_validation_at ? 'checked' : '';
+                            let manager_check = cert.manager_validation_at ? 'checked' : '';
+
                             let issuedate = '-';
                             let validationBadge = '';
+                            let statusBadge = '';
 
                             if (issuedateRaw && issuedateRaw !== '0000-00-00') {
                                 let date = new Date(issuedateRaw);
@@ -204,13 +209,44 @@ $(function () {
                             }
 
                             if (status == 'unvalidated') {
-                                validationBadge = '<div class=""><span class="badge bg-warning text-dark">unvalidated</span></div>';
+                                // validationBadge = "<div class=''><span class='badge bg-warning text-dark'>unvalidated</span><br></div>";
+                                validationBadge = '<div class="">' +
+                                                    '<span class="badge bg-warning text-dark mb-1 p-1 px-2">unvalidated</span><br>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check text-sm">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + user_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">TSO</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + spv_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">SPV</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + manager_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">Manager</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                '</div>';
+                                statusBadge = '<span class="text-danger">❋</span>';
                             } else {
-                                validationBadge = '<div class=""><span class="badge bg-success">validated</span></div>';
+                                // validationBadge = '<div class=""><span class="badge bg-success">validated</span></div>';
+                                validationBadge = '<div class="">' +
+                                                    '<span class="badge bg-success mb-1 p-1 px-2">validated</span><br>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + user_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">TSO</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + spv_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">SPV</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                    '<div class="form-check">' +
+                                                        '<input class="form-check-input" type="checkbox" ' + manager_check + ' disabled>' +
+                                                        '<label class="form-check-label small">Manager</label>' +
+                                                    '</div>' +
+                                                '</div>';
                             }
 
                             return [
-                                `<strong>${certname}</strong><br><small class="text-muted">Cert# : ${certnumber}</small>`,
+                                `<strong>${statusBadge} ${certname}</strong><br><small class="text-muted">Cert# : ${certnumber}</small>`,
                                 `<a href="javascript:void(0)" class="activity-report-link text-decoration-none" data-certid="${certid}" data-actid="${actid}" style="color:#d43215b0;">#${actid} - ${activity_subject} &nbsp;<i class="fa-solid fa-up-right-from-square"></i></strong><br><small class="text-muted">Owner : ${fullname}</small></a>`,
                                 issuedate,
                                 validationBadge,